This is about the time of year that everyone is putting out their top 10 lists of stuff that happened in the previous year. As a big music fan, my list of choice is a top 10 albums list. But the thing is, it hardly seems fair for me to try and list the top 10 albums of 2004. I mean, what if something amazing came out in December that I haven't listened to? So I'm going to play it safe and list my top 10 albums of the year before. I've still probably missed some great ones, but it's at least a bit more accurate. Here goes:
Top 10 Albums of 2003
10. Ulrich Schnauss - A Strangely Isolated Place
Superbly crafted electronica. (
edit: You might notice I originally had The Dears -
No Cities Left as #10, but after looking again, I realized that it came out in 2004. This is probably a better album anyway.)
9. The Unicorns - Unicorns Are People Too
Just good indie pop. Period. End of sentence.
8. Metric - Old World Underground, Where Are You Now?
Math-punk? Damn right, and damn good too. The fact that the singer is an attractive Canadian girl is just icing. They're playing at the
Elixir in a few weeks, too!
7. Radiohead - Hail to the Thief
So maybe it wasn't
OK Computer. At least it wasn't
Kid A. (Not that
Kid A isn't also a cool album too in its own right.) This one shows that Radiohead can still do rock, and still do it as well as ever without repeating themselves.
6. The Stills - Logic Will Break Your Heart
There's nothing too exciting about these guys, except that they play really good rock and roll songs. Good Montreal boys.
5. M. Ward - Transfiguration of Vincent
Folk-rock Americana singer/songwriter concept albums at their best.
4. Holopaw - Holopaw
This album blew me away as soon as I heard it. Acoustic alt. country as carefully crafted as a fine beer.
3. Songs: Ohia - Magnolia Electric Co.
Jason Molina puts out another winner.
Magnolia's rich arrangements are a sharp contrast to dark working-class ballads of 2002's
Didn't It Rain. Too bad they butchered "The Old Black Hen" by letting Lawrence Peters sing it; check out the solo acoustic version on the bonus disc instead.
2. My Morning Jacket - It Still Moves
This album was a dramatic departure from their first two releases (which I also loved), but Jim James and Co. pulled it off. If you had told me back in 2002 that MMJ would get rid of their lo-fi alt. country sound in favour of overdubbing and loud guitars, I would have been worried (after I got over the whole "My Morning
Who?" issue), but it's fantastic--maybe my favorite MMJ album.
1. Grandaddy - Sumday
I hate to give the #1 spot to a bunch of guys who write all their songs about robots and frolicking in the forest, but I have no choice. Simply put, every track on this album is great.
Year's Biggest Disappointment:
Zwan - Mary, Star of the Sea
Remember how over-produced the last Smashing Pumpkins album was? Well, multiply that by five and you'll see why this album wasn't that great. Then throw in a nine-minute song about Jesus and some fluorescent psychedelic-wannabe cover art and you get the picture. The songwriting is decent, but it's
so poorly executed. And hey Billy Corgan, why didn't you stop being such a control freak and let David Pajo or Matt Sweeney do some of the songs? I mean, NEWS FLASH: they've both put out more good albums than you have in the last five years. No wonder this band didn't live to see 2004.