Hello all, and welcome to my third annual retrospective on the best music of the year before. (See also:
2004,
2003). 2005 was a great year for music, and 2006 looks set to be even better. Here it is:
10. The New Pornographers - Twin CinemaMore goodness from Vancouver-based New Pornographers. It's not a great advancement on their first two albums, but it still has lots of memorable, catchy tunes, and a few really good ones too, like "Use It" and "Streets of Fire."
9. Spoon - Gimme FictionI have to admit, I probably would have forgotten all about this album if so many of its songs hadn't been featured in the movie
Stranger than Fiction, which was probably my favorite movie of 2006. Spoon is consistently awesome.
8. Gorillaz - Demon DaysYeah, I know: they're cartoons. But they're cartoons who perform songs by Damon Albarn. It's full of great songs.
7. My Morning Jacket - ZMy first reaction upon listening to this album was "WTF? This doesn't sound like MMJ!" It took a while to grow on me, but I eventually took it for what it was: innovative and high quality music by one of my favorite bands.
6. Magnolia Electric Co. - What Comes After the BluesThe Magnolia album before it was better. The Magnolia album after it was better. But this one was still pretty darn good. I just can't say anything bad about Jason Molina.
5. Matt Sweeney and Bonnie 'Prince' Billy - SuperwolfA collaboration between two of my favorite musicians, Matt Sweeney of Chavez (probably the most underrated band of the '90s) and Bonnie Billy, a.k.a. Will Oldham. Good, country-ish stuff.
4. Wolf Parade - Apologies to the Queen MaryI'm always a bit skeptical of the up-and-coming trendy local band, but these guys really have it. Not to be confused with another up-and-coming trendy Montreal band, the absolutely awful AIDS Wolf. Gee, I hope none of the wolves in the parade have AIDS.
3. David Thomas Broughton - The Complete Guide to Insufficiency
This was one of those albums that makes your jaw drop with its originality. It makes your jaw drop a lot more when you actually see DTB perform live, and quickly realize that the album was recorded live, in one take, without any backing musicians. It's a little hard to explain: he sings and plays acoustic guitar, and he samples himself and then uses his own previous performance as the backing track, slowly building from a lone voice to a chorus. If you get a chance, see him live! As well as being innovative, the music is also beautiful.
2. Death Cab for Cutie - PlansThis is probably my most mainstream choice of the year, but it had to go in here because it's one of those albums that's just
good. Every song on it is good. I don't even care if you make fun of me for being emo.
1. Okkervil River - Black Sheep BoyIf this band is the only good thing
last.fm ever suggests to me (which, so far, it is), signing up will still have been the best investment of time I've ever made. I haven't been this excited about a band in years. This record is not just a collection of fantastic songs, it also holds together as a fantastic album, the best I've heard since Neutral Milk Hotel's
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea from 1998 (which is one of my three favorite albums ever)
. Listen to it if it's the last thing you do. Sad and beautiful.
Year's Biggest Disappointment:Beck - GueroI was hoping for something as good as
Mutations. I thought at least I'd get something as good as
Sea Change. Instead, I got something that tried to sound a lot like
Odelay and came off just plain unoriginal. Other than the first single "E-Pro," this album is totally forgettable.
Honorable Mentions:Sufjan Stevens'
Illinoise! made everyone else's top 10 list for 2005. I think it's a good album, but after a year of hindsight, it didn't quite make the cut. Billy Corgan's
The Future Embrace was a hell of a lot better than I'd expected, but still not top 10 material. And Holopaw's
Quit and/or Fight was also pretty freaking good, but there just wasn't room.